The world of e-commerce is booming, with more entrepreneurs than ever launching their online businesses. But choosing the right platform to build your online store can be overwhelming. Two popular options are Shopify and Amazon, each offering distinct advantages and drawbacks. 

This guide is designed to walk aspiring sellers through a comprehensive comparison of Shopify vs. Amazon, helping you make an informed decision based on your specific needs and goals. Whether you’re a seasoned entrepreneur or just starting your journey, this article will equip you with the knowledge to choose the platform that propels your business forward.

Shopify vs. Amazon Platform Overview

More than just a platform to sell on, Shopify and Amazon each have unique mechanics that lend to its ecommerce appeal. Before you make the choice to sell on one or both, take the time to understand what each has to offer and how they work.

Shopify: An Innovative Selling Platform

Shopify is a user-friendly platform designed specifically for building e-commerce stores. Think of it as your own digital storefront, complete with customizable themes, product listings, and shopping cart functionality. You can choose from a vast library of professionally designed themes or even create your own unique brand identity. 

Shopify also empowers sellers with marketing tools like email campaigns, social media integration, and discount codes to attract customers and boost sales. Additionally, it integrates seamlessly with various third-party apps, allowing you to expand your store’s functionality with features like inventory management and shipping automation. 

Shopify offers different subscription plans, catering to businesses of all sizes, starting from $29 per month.

Amazon: A Global eCommerce Giant

Amazon, on the other hand, is a giant online marketplace where millions of consumers shop daily. Instead of building your own store, you’re essentially setting up a virtual booth within Amazon’s vast marketplace. This translates to instant access to a massive audience, eliminating the need to build traffic from scratch. Plus, Amazon offers fulfillment services through its Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) program, where you send your products to Amazon’s warehouses and they handle storage, packing, and shipping. This can be a huge time-saver for busy entrepreneurs. 

Pricing for Amazon sellers varies depending on the plan you choose. The Individual plan requires a $0.99 per-item sold fee, while the Professional plan costs $39.99 per month but offers additional features like bulk product uploads and advanced reporting. However, it’s important to remember that Amazon takes a referral fee on each item sold, which can vary depending on the product category.

Looking to build your own ecommerce ecosystem? Shopify might be for you. For those willing to brave the competitive landscape in pursuit customer exposure, Amazon offers potential. It’s important for sellers to understand how they want to sell before deciding on Shopify vs. Amazon. 

A Brief Comparison of Selling on Shopify vs. Amazon

Not only are the platforms themselves geared toward different types of selling, the features and capabilities of each platform are also diverse. Choosing the right platform hinges on understanding the fundamental differences between Shopify and Amazon. Here are the key differences to consider:

  • Ownership and Control: Shopify provides sellers with more control over their store, allowing them to own their website and have full control over its design, branding, and customization. On the other hand, selling on Amazon means operating within Amazon’s ecosystem, where sellers have less control over branding and customer experience compared to having their own Shopify store.
  • Branding and Customization: With Shopify, sellers can fully customize their online store to reflect their brand identity, leveraging a wide range of themes and customization options. Conversely, on Amazon, while sellers can create their own brand presence, they are limited in terms of customization. Product pages on Amazon have a standardized layout and sellers have less control over branding compared to Shopify.
  • Fulfillment Options: Shopify offers integration with various third-party fulfillment services or allows sellers to fulfill orders themselves, in addition to Shopify Fulfillment Network for warehousing and order fulfillment. Amazon provides Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), enabling sellers to store products in Amazon’s warehouses and utilize Amazon’s logistics network for order fulfillment, potentially offering faster shipping and Prime eligibility.
  • Fees: Shopify charges monthly subscription fees based on the chosen plan, along with transaction fees for each sale. Amazon charges referral fees (a percentage of each sale), fulfillment fees (if using FBA), and subscription fees for certain seller plans (e.g., Amazon Professional Selling Plan).
  • Traffic and Exposure: While Shopify equips sellers with tools for SEO, marketing, and social media integration, sellers are responsible for driving traffic to their Shopify store. In contrast, Amazon offers access to a massive customer base, providing built-in traffic and extensive exposure for sellers, potentially leading to higher sales with less marketing.
  • Customer Data: Sellers using Shopify have full access to customer data collected through their store, including contact information, purchase history, and other valuable insights. On Amazon, while sellers can access some customer data like shipping addresses and order details, Amazon retains control over much of the customer data collected on its platform.
  • International Expansion: Shopify offers tools and integrations to facilitate international expansion, such as multi-currency support, language translation, and localized storefronts. Amazon has a presence in multiple countries and allows sellers to sell internationally through its various marketplaces, albeit with compliance requirements and potential language and cultural barriers.

Put simply, while both platforms allow you to list products and sell them, how sellers go about transacting can be very different on Shopify vs. Amazon. It comes down to whether you prefer to build your own ecommerce empire or participate to a bustling marketplace that already exists. 

The Pros and Cons of Selling on Shopify vs. Amazon

Looking for a tl;dr for the pros and cons of selling Shopify vs. Amazon? Here’s a quick breakdown of each platform’s strengths for sellers, as well as potential weaknesses to be aware of if you choose that platform:

Shopify: More Control, More Work

  • [PRO] Build your brand and unique identity.
  • [PRO] Full control over design and user experience.
  • [PRO] Diverse marketing and SEO options.
  • [PRO] Lower competition within your niche.
  • [CON] Requires effort to build traffic and attract customers.
  • [CON] No built-in audience, starting from scratch.
  • [CON] Higher fees compared to Amazon’s Individual plan (optional).

Amazon: Less Control, Less Work

  • [PRO] Large existing audience, instant access to millions of potential buyers.
  • [PRO] Convenient FBA fulfillment option saves time and resources.
  • [PRO] Lower barrier to entry, easier to start selling quickly.
  • [CON] Limited control over branding and customer experience.
  • [CON] Highly competitive marketplace, visibility requires paid advertising.
  • [CON] Fees can add up, including referral fees and potential FBA costs.

How you approach selling will dictate which platform is right for you. Are you willing to burden more work for more control over your selling? Or do you prefer an established selling framework and audience at the expense of some autonomy?

North One Helps You Succeed on Any Platform

Choosing the right e-commerce platform is a crucial step towards launching your online business successfully. By understanding the distinct advantages and drawbacks of Shopify vs. Amazon, and carefully considering your unique business goals, you can make an informed decision that sets your online journey on the path to success.

No matter which platform you choose to sell on, North One makes it easy to monitor your cash flows. Sync your storefront to your North One account and check out revenue analytics through your Revenue Dashboard, to see when every dollar you’ve earned becomes cash you can spend. You can spend less time worrying about finances and more time doing what you do best: selling. 

Apply for a North One Connected Banking account: